Top Designated Hitters of All Time

Posted on June 1st, 2013 by admin

First enacted in 1973, the designated hitter has come to play a prominent role within the sport of baseball over the past few decades.  Because the position is only available in the American League, it gives baseball memorabilia collectors not only another area of interest to focus on, but another way to enjoy collecting in general as well.  Arguments have been raging back and forth as to whether there should even be a designated hitter or if it should be implemented in both leagues, but regardless it is likely here to stay for a significant amount of time.  What follows are some of the most accomplished designated hitters to have played the game to this point.

Jim Thome

One of the more prevalent power hitters of the modern era, Thome will likely go down as one of the best designated hitters of all time as well.  Having played over 20 years in Major League Baseball, Jim racked up over 600 home runs, 1,600 RBIs and well over 2,000 hits to go with a .276 average as well.  He was selected to five All Star games over the course of his career and should easily make it into the Hall of Fame on the first ballot, making Thome appealing to baseball memorabilia collectors.

Jim-Thome-baseball-card

Frank Thomas

Frank Thomas was one of the giants of the game during the modern era as well, but what separates him from someone like Thome was his ability to hit for average as well as power.  Frank hit over 520 home runs for his career to go with a sparkling .301 average along with over 2,400 hits as well.  Thomas was in his prime for the Chicago White Sox during the early 1990’s when he won the AL MVP award in 1993 and 1994, and his memorabilia is still highly collectible today.

Frank-Thomas-baseball-card

Edgar Martinez

Martinez was most known for his role as a designated hitter for the Seattle Mariners during his nearly 20 year career.  Edgar hit over .310 for his career with nearly 2,300 hits and over 300 home runs as well, and went to the All Star game on seven occasions.  One of the most defining aspects of his time in Major League Baseball is that the best designated hitter award for each year is named in his honor with the Edgar Martinez Award.  Unfortunately Martinez has not been elected into the Hall of Fame yet, but that should not take away from his memorabilia value.

Edgar-Martinez-baseball-card

Paul Molitor

Unlike many designated hitters these days who mostly hit for power with a little bit of average as well, Paul Molitor mostly hit for average and had tremendous speed on the basepaths.  Molitor had a .306 average for his career along with over 3,000 hits and 500 stolen bases.  He was selected to seven All Star games and won the Silver Slugger award on four different occasions as well.  Paul was elected in to the Hall of Fame in 2004 with over 85% of the vote and remains popular among memorabilia aficionados.

Paul-Molitor-baseball-card



1990 Bowman Frank Thomas RC -Wrong Back ERROR -Graded BGS 9.5 - Only 2 Exist picture
1990 Bowman Frank Thomas RC -Wrong Back ERROR -Graded BGS 9.5 – Only 2 Exist
$75000.0


⚾️ 1990 Topps Frank Thomas 414B RC Authentic Autograph 10, MT - GEM MT Card ⚾️ picture
⚾️ 1990 Topps Frank Thomas 414B RC Authentic Autograph 10, MT – GEM MT Card ⚾️
$50000.0


Frank Thomas 1998 Donruss Elite # 2 Embossed Redemption Autograph PSA 9 Mint picture
Frank Thomas 1998 Donruss Elite # 2 Embossed Redemption Autograph PSA 9 Mint
$34999.95


PSA 10 Frank Thomas -  #1 1997 Skybox E-X 2000 A Cut Above. POP 4. GEM MINT. picture
PSA 10 Frank Thomas –  #1 1997 Skybox E-X 2000 A Cut Above. POP 4. GEM MINT.
$25000.0


Topps Project 2020 Frank Thomas by Ben Baller BBDTC Autograph 14/100 picture
Topps Project 2020 Frank Thomas by Ben Baller BBDTC Autograph 14/100
$15000.0


1990 Topps Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC, NO NAME #414A JSA BGS 8.5 NM-MT+ picture
1990 Topps Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC, NO NAME #414A JSA BGS 8.5 NM-MT+
$13500.0


1990 Topps Frank Thomas #414 No Name on Front NNOF PSA 7 NM Near Mint picture
1990 Topps Frank Thomas #414 No Name on Front NNOF PSA 7 NM Near Mint
$12500.0


1990 topps #414 frank thomas nnof hof rc; holy grail signed auto psa 1 - what? picture
1990 topps #414 frank thomas nnof hof rc; holy grail signed auto psa 1 – what?
$11999.99


1990 Topps Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC, NO NAME ON FRONT #414 PSA Auth, Altered picture
1990 Topps Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC, NO NAME ON FRONT #414 PSA Auth, Altered
$10000.0


1990 Leaf Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC PSA/DNA AUTO #300 PSA 10 GEM MINT picture
1990 Leaf Frank Thomas ROOKIE RC PSA/DNA AUTO #300 PSA 10 GEM MINT
$10000.0


 2013  BOWMAN  D P  AARON JUDGE  ROOKIE / NO NAME / FOIL  ERROR 1/1 FRANK THOMAS picture
2013 BOWMAN D P AARON JUDGE ROOKIE / NO NAME / FOIL ERROR 1/1 FRANK THOMAS
$9999.99


1990 Topps Frank Thomas NNOF RC Error Card #414 ASA 8PQ-Mt picture
1990 Topps Frank Thomas NNOF RC Error Card #414 ASA 8PQ-Mt
$9999.0


    Next Page >>