Polar Opposites – David Freese for Peter Bourjos

Posted on December 14th, 2013 by Matt

The St. Louis Cardinals have a well-earned reputation as one of the best-run franchises in all of baseball. One look at their recent resume would suggest that they do, in fact, know what they are doing. A constant presence in the playoffs, the Cardinals seem well-positioned to remain as a force in the National League for many years to come.

The Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim, on the other hand, seem to be trending in the opposite direction. After a very successful first decade of the new century, the Angels have started throwing money at their problems – only to end up with more problems. The last two off seasons have seen the Angels making the biggest splash, first with Albert Pujols, and next with Josh Hamilton. Neither of those moves have paid off to this point, and the Angels appear to be going nowhere fast.

An Obvious Move for St. Loius

Given the fact that the Angels have a glut of outfielders and no third baseman to speak of, the Cardinals made sense as trade partners. The Cardinals have plenty of infielders to go around, but were a little thin in bourjosthe outfield department – especially center. Peter Bourjos is one of the fastest players in baseball and a great defensive outfielder. In addition, he hits better, and for more power, than your average speedy outfielder. When he can stay healthy, Bourjos is an enviable player that forces the opponent into a lot of uncomfortable positions.

But Not for the Angels

While it is easy to see why the Cardinals would be interested in Bourjos, it is not so obvious why the Angels would be willing to deal him for David Freese. Although Freese will live in St. Louis history forever after his amazing 2011 World Series performance, his 2013 campaign left a lot to be desired. He posted career lows in just about every category, and flopped in a big way in October. He is only under contract for two more years, as opposed to three for Bourjos, and will be more expensive to boot. Sure, the Angels needed a third baseman, but way Freese? And freesewhy give up Bourjos?

Seemingly One-Sided

As it stands, this trade seems like an easy win for the Cardinals. They addressed a significant need without having to part with anything of too much value or pay high free agent prices. The only obviously trouble that could be lurking on St. Louis end is the injury trouble that seems to follow Bourjos. If he can stay on the field, he’s an asset – but that’s a big if. For Anaheim, the deal seems less than desirable. Sure, Freese could rebound and be a useful player for the next couple years, but there is a chance that his useful days are behind him. Typically, hitters numbers get worse when moving from the National to American league, and Freese certainly can’t afford to go down much from where he was in 2013. It will all play out in time, but St. Louis fans sure have to feel better about this deal as it looks today.


David Freese St. Louis Cardinals Majestic MLB Home White Jersey Mens XL - FADED picture

David Freese St. Louis Cardinals Majestic MLB Home White Jersey Mens XL - FADED

$19.99



David Freese 2014 Topps Museum Collection Primary Pieces Quad Relic Auto 3/10 picture

David Freese 2014 Topps Museum Collection Primary Pieces Quad Relic Auto 3/10

$199.99



David Freese 2012 Prime Cuts Timeline Trios Materials Signatures MVP Auto 2/5  picture

David Freese 2012 Prime Cuts Timeline Trios Materials Signatures MVP Auto 2/5

$149.99



David Freese Autographed Baseball, With Original CAO picture

David Freese Autographed Baseball, With Original CAO

$117.00



2012 Topps David Freese #291 St. Louis Cardinals picture

2012 Topps David Freese #291 St. Louis Cardinals

$1.59



David Freese Bobblehead 9/18/2021 St Louis Cardinals NIB  picture

David Freese Bobblehead 9/18/2021 St Louis Cardinals NIB

$20.00



2017 Topps Baseball Card Pick 251-499 picture

2017 Topps Baseball Card Pick 251-499

$0.99



2009 UPPER DECK ICONS DAVID FREESE AUTO ROOKIE RC CARDINALS /200 RED picture

2009 UPPER DECK ICONS DAVID FREESE AUTO ROOKIE RC CARDINALS /200 RED

$49.99



David Freese 2013 St. Louis Cardinals World Series White Home Men's Jersey picture

David Freese 2013 St. Louis Cardinals World Series White Home Men's Jersey

$119.99



Special Edition St Louis Post Dispatch Poster Framed David Freese World Series picture

Special Edition St Louis Post Dispatch Poster Framed David Freese World Series

$100.00